The Anatomy of a Defensible DCF: What Reviewers Question First
Checked against a desk review of the law dated 20 November 2026. That review relied partly on secondary sources and has not been signed off by a qualified professional. General information, not advice: read the notified text before relying on any point.
A discounted cash flow (DCF) valuation is only as strong as its ability to withstand review, whether by a tax officer, an authorised dealer bank, an auditor or the other side's adviser. This article sets out the assumptions and methodology choices that are questioned first. It is a practitioner's checklist, not a survey of decided cases.
Where DCF Is and Is Not the Legal Method
Check first whether the purpose calls for a DCF at all. For income-tax the fair market value of unquoted equity shares is a net-asset formula (Rule 11UA up to 31 March 2026, Rule 57 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 from 1 April 2026), and the DCF option that once supported share premium under section 56(2)(viib) fell away when that provision was omitted with effect from 1 April 2025. DCF remains relevant where the rule leaves the method to the valuer, for example a preferential allotment by an unlisted company, or the pricing of shares issued to a non-resident, where any internationally accepted pricing methodology may be used.
Revenue Growth Assumptions
Revenue growth projections are usually the first thing a reviewer tests. The common criticism is that projections are unrealistic or not supported by historical performance. A reviewer will compare projected growth against the company's own history, published industry growth and nominal GDP growth as a reasonableness check.
To build defensible revenue projections, valuers should anchor growth rates in historical performance, clearly disclose and justify any deviation from historical trends, reference industry reports and publicly available growth forecasts, include order book data or contracted revenue where available, and build projections bottom-up from specific business drivers rather than applying a top-down growth percentage.
WACC Components
The weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is examined component by component.
Risk-Free Rate Selection
The choice of government security yield used as the risk-free rate matters. A short-term T-bill yield sits badly with a projection period of five to ten years. Match the tenor of the instrument to the projection period, typically the 10-year Government of India benchmark yield on the valuation date, and record the source and the date.
Equity Risk Premium
The equity risk premium (ERP) is an area where valuers have discretion, and discretion invites challenge. Using a widely accepted source such as Damodaran's country risk premium data, with clear disclosure of the source, the methodology (implied or historical) and the date of the data, reduces the risk of challenge.
Beta and Comparable Selection
When using a comparable company beta (necessary for private companies), the selection of comparable companies and the period over which beta is measured can significantly affect the WACC. Valuers should document the comparable selection criteria, the rationale for including or excluding specific companies, and the beta measurement period.
Terminal Value
The terminal value is often the larger part of enterprise value in a DCF. Despite its weight, terminal assumptions often receive less documentation than the explicit period. Expect a challenge where the terminal growth rate exceeds long-term growth expectations for the economy.
A defensible terminal growth rate should not exceed the long-term nominal GDP growth rate for the economy, should be lower than the explicit period growth rate (reflecting the company's transition to a mature state), and should be accompanied by sensitivity analysis showing the valuation impact of varying the terminal growth rate.
Working Capital and Capex Assumptions
Working capital and capital expenditure assumptions are open to challenge when they are a fixed percentage of revenue with no analysis of historical patterns. Analyze historical working capital days (receivables, inventory, payables) and capex patterns, and project them from the company's own operational characteristics rather than generic industry benchmarks.
Sensitivity Analysis
A sensitivity table showing the value under varying WACC and terminal growth rate assumptions shows that the valuer has considered a range of outcomes and that the concluded value falls within it. That makes it harder to argue that a different assumption would give a materially different value.
Documentation Standards
The quality of documentation often determines whether a valuation survives review. Every key assumption should be accompanied by its source, the rationale for the selected value, and the sensitivity of the final value to changes in that assumption. Working papers should demonstrate the analytical process, not just the final result.