Skip to main content
Back to Insights
Valuation Practice

Comparable Company Selection for Indian Private Companies: A Practitioner's Framework

Published March 2026Updated 20 November 20264 min read

Selecting appropriate comparable companies is one of the most judgment-intensive aspects of valuation practice. When the subject company is an unlisted Indian private company, the challenge is amplified by limited public information, different capital structures, and the need to justify comparability to stakeholders who may question the selected peers. This article presents a systematic framework for comparable selection.

Starting with the Universe: Where to Look

The initial screening universe for Indian comparable companies should be drawn from multiple sources. BSE and NSE listed companies provide the primary pool, accessible through databases such as CMIE Prowess, Capitaline, and Ace Equity. For sector-specific searches, NIC (National Industrial Classification) codes provide a structured starting point, though practitioners should not rely solely on NIC codes as they can be too broad or too narrow.

Industry association membership lists, trade publications, and the subject company's own competitive landscape as described in its business plans or industry presentations can supplement the database-driven search. For companies with international operations or in globally competitive sectors, extending the universe to include listed peers in relevant international markets may be appropriate.

Stage 1: Industry and Business Model Alignment

The first filter should focus on business model similarity, not just industry classification. A company manufacturing auto components for OEMs is not truly comparable to an auto component company focused on aftermarket sales, even though both carry the same NIC code. Key dimensions to evaluate include the company's position in the value chain, customer concentration and type, revenue model characteristics, and geographic market focus.

Stage 2: Size and Scale Screening

Size affects valuation multiples: smaller companies tend to trade at lower multiples because of higher risk, lower liquidity, and less diversification. The screening framework should define size parameters, for example a band of revenue around the subject company's, widened where the available universe is thin, and should state the band in the report.

Stage 3: Financial Profile Matching

Beyond size, the financial profile of comparable companies should reasonably match the subject. Key metrics to compare include revenue growth rates over several years, EBITDA margins and margin trends, capital intensity (capex as a percentage of revenue), return on invested capital, and leverage ratios. Companies with dramatically different financial profiles, even if in the same industry, may not be truly comparable.

Stage 4: Quality Filters

The final screening stage should exclude companies with characteristics that distort multiples: companies undergoing financial distress or restructuring, companies with recent significant M&A activity that distorts reported financials, companies with a short trading history, and companies where substantial related party transactions may affect reported performance.

Documenting the Selection Process

Proper documentation is the foundation for defending the comparable set. The valuation report should disclose the initial universe and the source databases used, each screening criterion and the quantitative thresholds applied, the number of companies surviving each screening stage, specific rationale for any manual inclusions or exclusions, and a summary table showing the final comparable set with key financial metrics.

Adjustments and Normalization

Once the comparable set is finalized, practitioners should consider the differences between the comparables and the subject company. Common adjustments include size adjustments, growth adjustments when growth rates differ meaningfully, margin adjustments, and control premium or minority discount adjustments depending on the interest being valued. Each adjustment needs its own evidence.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Several common mistakes undermine the credibility of comparable analysis. Cherry-picking only companies that support a predetermined conclusion is the most serious. Using stale multiples without regard to market conditions on the valuation date introduces inaccuracy. Applying multiples from a different economic cycle without adjustment can mislead. And failing to explain why certain obvious peers were excluded invites suspicion.

A well-constructed comparable analysis with transparent documentation provides an independent market-based reference point that supports the overall valuation conclusion.

How Peers Work in Evaaluate

In Evaaluate named listed peers are added by hand, pasted from an export of a database the firm already uses, or fetched from a market-data provider if a key has been configured on the deployment. Each peer carries its source and the date its multiples describe. Nothing is selected automatically: the valuer chooses the set, records a reason for each exclusion, and must confirm the selection before the inputs can be locked.